Staff Essays

A review of 'Gigli'

Science Fiction and Fantasy: Xenite.Org -- Worlds of Imagination on the Web!
Staff Essay Headlines
A review of 'Gigli' posted
Xenite.Org Staff Essays
A review of 'Gigli'

Site map

News headlines


Special thanks to:
Stacey Capps
for designing
Xenite.org's graphics


Contact Us!
by Dean Kish
August 03, 2003 at 11:55:30

Most of my fellow media writers have said that 'Gigli' is probably the worst film of the year. Some have compared it to being as awful as 'Ishtar'. I usually don't let my fellow writers influence my critiques but the backlash towards this film seems unavoidable.

I wouldn't go as far as comparing it to infamous box office disasters like "Ishtar" and "Hudson Hawk". For me I compare it to the sci-fi crumbler "Battlefield: Earth". Why? Well let's talk about what the film is really about first.

Larry Gigli (Ben Affleck) is your typical run-of-the-mill Mafia thug. He's full of himself, a player with the ladies and loves his job. Gigli is given an assignment by his connection to the mob, Louis (Lenny Venito), to kidnap Brian (Justin Bartha), the younger brother of a significant District Attorney.

Gigli is ecstatic about his new job and snags the younger brother only to find out that he is psychologically challenged. Gigli has no patience with this. If that wasn't bad enough for Gigli, his boss sticks him with Rikki (Jennifer Lopez), a fellow Mafia thug who also happens to be a lesbian. Can Gigli get through this assignment without screwin' up? Who knows?

"Gigli" was destined to be a train-wreck even if super couple Ben and Jen hadn't been in the movie. With jokes involving the Gigli character screaming at Brian to shut-up or a come-hither scene that opens with the line, "It's turkey time", you know you have hit rock bottom in the romantic comedy field.

Let's place the script aside and focus on the story for a moment. You have a Mafia thug seducing a much disciplined lesbian. For one thing, neither character has anything in common. Another thing: if you are going to have a lesbian in a movie, why do you always have to dumb her down. Why make her a lesbian at all?

One of the better scenes in the film does involve lesbian Lopez putting street-thug Affleck in his place after he proclaims that men are the world's center of passion. The second and final better scene is at the film's conclusion when Brian's dream comes true. I guess I liked Brian enough to want to see him be happy.

Justin Bartha's Brian is a good solid performance and he shows how literally dull a movie with heavy-weights like Affleck, Lopez, Al Pacino and Christopher Walken can be. The cameos by Pacino and Walken are utterly forgettable and a waste of time in their esteemed careers. Pacino rants and fires a gun; well, gee, been there done that how many times?

So what do "Gigli" and "Battlefield: Earth" have in common? Well, each film has an awful script followed by a couple of isolated stand-out moments. Each film is a rock-bottom candidate for each's genre. Finally, both films have a main character that is a relative unknown who outshines even the strongest of actors: Barry Pepper in "Earth" and Bartha in "Gigli". Maybe my comparison will hold but it is just one guy's opinion. (1 out of 5) So Says the Soothsayer.





This page is copyright © 1997-2003 by Michael L. Martinez. All rights reserved.
No portions of this page may be reproduced electronically or otherwise without express permission from the copyright holder, except as occurs in normal browser caching and page indexing.

Created by Michael Martinez

The opinions expressed in these essays are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of the Xenite.Org owner(s), administrator(s), forum moderators, volunteer staff, or community members. Xenite.Org provides this essay posting service as a courtesy to its volunteer staff members, including but not necessarily limited to content editors, forum moderators and administrators, and service administrators. If you would like to assist in the online development and management of Xenite.Org, please contact the Xenite.Org Administrators.