Staff Essays

A review of 'Gothika'

Science Fiction and Fantasy: Xenite.Org -- Worlds of Imagination on the Web!
Staff Essay Headlines
A review of 'Gothika' posted
Xenite.Org Staff Essays
A review of 'Gothika'

Site map

News headlines


Special thanks to:
Stacey Capps
for designing
Xenite.org's graphics


Contact Us!
by Dean Kish
November 22, 2003 at 16:14:11

Halle Berry goes crazy and 'rings' a little to close to another popular horror film.

Halle Berry stars as psychiatrist Miranda Grey, who works in an elaborate mental institution headed by her husband, Dr. Douglas Grey (Charles S. Dutton). Miranda's friend Pete (Robert Downey Jr.) also works with Doug and Miranda.

During a freakish rainstorm, the institution suffers from several power-outages and forces Miranda to return home to Doug. During her trip home, she is detoured across a country bridge where she narrowly misses a naked girl wandering in of the middle road.

This is all Miranda can remember. And now she has just awoke within the walls of her own institution not as a doctor but as a patient. Is she crazy? She might just be because during her memory relapse, she also murdered Doug.
The first half of the film has a lot of the tension and paranoia audiences felt in last year's horror phenomenon "The Ring" but by the second half I was waiting for Morgan Freeman's Alex Cross to come out from the shadows and solve Halle's case.

Halle Berry's desperation, sweat-soaked institution attire and frayed hair add oodles to her powerful performance. But even as the role does allow her to go way over the top we still don't feel a lot for her character. Within this performance is some of what we got in "Monster's Ball" but not enough to make the film really captivate.

Downey Jr. is bored to tears in the pining for Halle role. It is such a waste to see such a natural and brilliant actor reduced to this "Demerol-induced" drone.

The performance by Penelope Cruz is strong and daring. It is her scenes with Halle that are the most memorable of this film. The two actresses together are quite impressive as we can see them feeding off each other.

The whole mass patient shower scene where Halle is struck down was in such poor taste that I was literally shaking my head thinking was I actually seeing a late-night "Cinemax" moment on the silver screen. It was awful; probably the worst excuse for a shower scene since "Starship Troopers".

The film did have a few frights and some very interesting camera angles. Some of the slow motion effects and visual effects were impressive and made for nice moody mental moments. But for the most part we had seen all of it before.

It is a shame this is Halle's first giant role since her Oscar win but without Halle and some clever camera uses, this could have been a "Full Moon Entertainment" horror film instead of a "Dark Castle" production. Oh and one last thing, "The Ring" girl is back (2 out of 5) So Says the Soothsayer.

Contact Dean Kish





This page is copyright © 1997-2003 by Michael L. Martinez. All rights reserved.
No portions of this page may be reproduced electronically or otherwise without express permission from the copyright holder, except as occurs in normal browser caching and page indexing.

Created by Michael Martinez

The opinions expressed in these essays are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of the Xenite.Org owner(s), administrator(s), forum moderators, volunteer staff, or community members. Xenite.Org provides this essay posting service as a courtesy to its volunteer staff members, including but not necessarily limited to content editors, forum moderators and administrators, and service administrators. If you would like to assist in the online development and management of Xenite.Org, please contact the Xenite.Org Administrators.